This easy tomato jam recipe bottles up the all the delicious flavor of ripe summer tomatoes so you can enjoy it year-round. It a versatile condiment that’s delicious on a cracker with cheese, slathered onto a burger, or by the spoonful!

small jar of tomato jam on a wooden counter.

What you’ll love about this recipe:

Year-Round Flavor: Extend the joy of summer by preserving the intense tomato goodness for any season.
Versatile Condiment: Elevate your meals with a jam that pairs perfectly with everything from burgers to grilled cheese.
A Great Homemade Gift: Making this tomato jam is a fun way to create something special for loved ones.

Do you remember the recipe that made you fall in love with cooking? When my friend Colleen asked me that question, it took me about two seconds to answer. This tomato jam recipe, from The Little House Cookbook, is the first truly spectacular thing I ever made.

I still remember the day my mom and I made it.

It was the summer before I started fourth grade and it was probably right around this time of year, when our garden was giving us more tomatoes than we could eat. We picked some tomatoes that were still green and fried them, then we preserved some of the ripest ones by making the best tomato jam.

I gave a jar of it to my teacher for Christmas that winter. When we came back from break, she told the entire class how amazing it was and how she had already finished the whole jar. Being the super shy kid that I was, I was humiliated.

When she pointed out that my face was turning the same color as the jam I wanted to crawl under my desk and disappear.

I won’t lie – I might have cried.

But secretly, I loved that she loved it.

I already loved to cook, but that was the moment when I fell in love with cooking for other people. Making something that would make them smile. Or something that would remind them of summer in the middle of a very, very long New York winter.

Ingredient’s You’ll Need

Ripe Tomatoes: For the best results, use 2 pounds of ripe plum tomatoes, with the cores removed. if you’re lucky enough to find them, it’s also delicious made with green tomatoes!
Light Brown Sugar: Brown sugar gives the jam a richer flavor than using regular sugar. If you only have dark brown sugar, you can combine it in equal parts with white sugar.
Lemon Juice: Lemon juice to balances the sweetness and ensure the acid levels are high enough. It’s important to use bottled lemon juice in this recipe, since the acidity is more consistent than fresh juice.
Lemon Zest: For an a burst of citrus flavor.
Freshly Grated Ginger: Use 1 teaspoon of grated fresh ginger for a hint of spice, or 1/4 teaspoon of ground ginger if you prefer.
Half-Pint Canning Jars: If you choose to can the jam for long-term storage, you’ll need sterilized 2 half-pint jars. When canning, follow proper canning procedures and guidelines for safety.

Recipe Tips

If you prefer a smoother consistency, you can strain out the skin and seeds before adding the jam to the jars. Don’t do this before cooking though, since they contain the natural pectin needed to help the jam set.

What does tomato jam taste like?

Tomatoes probably aren’t the first thing that come to mind when you think about jam, but they work beautifully. It’s sticky and sweet, with a super concentrated tomato flavor. And no, it doesn’t taste a thing like ketchup. It has all of the bright summer tomato flavor that tomatoes you can buy in the winter lack.

How to use tomato jam

Once you taste it, you’ll find a million ways to use this savory jam. I love it on crackers (with or without a little creamy goat cheese or cream cheese), spread on a grilled cheese sandwich (try it mozzarella and pesto for a wintertime caprese), or on burgers. You can also combine it with balsamic vinegar to make a lovely marinade for steak or mix it with cumin for a fantastic chutney-like accompaniment to chicken breast or fish.

What are the best tomatoes for jam?

Plum tomatoes are perfect for jam because they’re nice and meaty, with a bright tomato flavor. You can use any tomatoes you happen to have though. Green tomatoes are also fantastic! Just be sure to use the ripest summer tomatoes that you can get your hands on for the best flavor.

How long does tomato jam keep in the fridge?

Sealed tightly, this tomato jam will keep well in the refrigerator for about 2 weeks or in the freezer for about 6 months. You can also can the jam for longer storage. If you’re interested in tomato jam canning, you can seal the jars in a hot water bath. If your choose to can your jam, be sure to use bottled lemon juice rather than fresh, since it’s has a more consistent pH level.

Can I double or triple the recipe?

Yes, but it will take much longer to reduce to the right consistency.

Looking for more tomato recipes to make this summer? We love Creamy Tomato Basil Soup, Steak with Smokey Tomato Relish, and Smoked Tomato and Bacon Vinaigrette.

More DIY condiment recipes you’ll love: